Well, on the opposite end of the spectrum not everything was peachy in the final year of the decade, as 2009 also proved to cough up some mighty horrid celluloid nightmares (and not in the good sense of the word), many of these worthy of sacrificial bonfire burnings. Living in Australia, however, we still have not yet received all titles currently available in the U.S and thus it was somewhat difficult to compile a Bottom 10 turd list. Featured here instead is a Bottom 5, each an abomination to the word 'horror' as we know it.
5. Twilight: New Moon
Okay, I understand it may be a little bit of a stretch including this in a list of horror movies - good, bad or otherwise - but this hopelessly melodramatic teeny wet-dream still features vampires, no matter how much they may sulk or sparkle. Right from the get-go the movie makes its agenda abundantly clear: sacrifice any and all filmmaking integrity known to man and instead cater to the naive' lusts of high school girls in the most predictable, by-the-book soap opera possible. Horrible performances, cringe-worthy dialogue and some of the worst CGI creature renditions in recent memory, this is one sequel who's success is sold purely on its 'hot' young cast...and nothing more. Bring on Eclipse . Not!
4. My Bloody Valentine 3D
Another inclusion which will probably have me burned at the stake by most genre fans is this slasher redux, made distinguishable from the original by its three dimensional gimmickry. However, it is precisely this marketing ploy that most felt made the movie the success that is was that I had the most problem with. For me any sincerity the film may have had was swiftly done away with through use of the goofy 4th-wall defying technology, resulting in a groan-fest, NOT a gore-fest. Sure, Tom Atkins' Sheriff, the 8 minute nude sequence, practical make-up effects and old-school sensibility were much appreciated but all ended up being severely undermined as a result. And it didn't help much either that Jensen Ackles spent half the movie in a perplexed daze or that the final 'twist' is by far the dumbest excuse for a movie massacre since...I don't know. It's just plain dumb.
3. Orphan
Were it not for Isabelle Fuhrman's sharp performance and the ludicrous twist at the end then maybe this would have been closer to being number 1. Matter of fact, the movie is worth the price of a rental based on its sheer idiocy alone. Final revelations aside, this irritating, painfully formulaic killer kid movie telegraphed every plot turn and character motivation so far in advance there was practically no point in sticking around - even for the revenge-driven finale. Ultimately it's up to you whether or not you can forgive the insanely long running time, Peter Sarsgaard's languid performance or even the fact that no one in the movie seemed to think that a 9-year old Russian girl who paints impressively, plays classical music, dresses in conservative 30's attire and likes to watch her adopted parents have sex is just a tad...odd.
2. The Unborn
David S. Goyer the screenwriter is far more adept than David S. Goyer the director. Or so it would seem thus far in his career. His written work on films such as Dark City, Batman Begins and The Dark Knight have all been terrific examples of strong storytelling and a specific vision adhering to the laws of cinema, however things always seem to flounder when it comes to helming a feature of his own. Case in point: The Unborn . This premature nightmare is riddled with plot holes, contrived story turns, poor pacing - even a 'homage' to The Exorcist spider-walk that instead comes of as a straight rip off. There are many other problems with the film but the real tragedy is Goyer's insistence on taking potentially interesting ideas and sugar coating them so thickly that they only appeal to the widest audience possible. As a filmmaker, Goyer is capable of A LOT better.
1. The Final Destination
I have never - I repeat - NEVER wanted to walk out of a cinema more than during the session I attended of The Final Destination . How New Line Cinema, director David R. Ellis or any of the cast and crew could have possibly thought they were making a remotely good movie with this the 4th (and final?) entry in the immensely lucrative franchise is beyond me. Ham-fisted, senseless and completely deviod of any excitement or cinematic trickery - in spite of the cockamamie 3D - this is easily the worst in the series and surely spells a nail in the coffin for the grim reaper-avenging gimmick. At least Glen Morgan and James Wong's 2000 original sustained a nice atmosphere and the subsequent sequels showcased some remarkably innovative kills. This monstrosity, however, made the pre-feature commercials seem more entertaining.
What say you, cretans?